It is well known what degree of mutual love and mutual help exists between people who all bear the same sign, which forms for them a sort of covenant and alliance. 
Moses Maimonides

Is circumcision a physical mark of ethnic or religious belonging? Yes, it is because certain religions enforce it. However, bearing a scar on private parts is a quite ineffective method of self-identification. Secret physical signs are pointless in distinguishing infidels except in some public baths. Far more obvious but harmless and painless wounds could be inflicted. Although circumcision indeed serves for group identification its main goal must be somewhere deeper. Yet religions must be acquainted with it.

For a person is not a Jew because of his appearance, nor is circumcision something just external and physical.
Bible, Romans 2:28

In any case, a physical mark that affects emotion and mind is actually a spiritual mark. As far as foreskin is sensitive it is an organ of thinking. As far as it is an organ of pleasure it is a spiritual organ. The fact that foreskin is an important erogenous zone means that paedocircumcision leaves not merely a scar on the skin but more importantly it marks the soul. Therefore, circumcision is not only a physical external symbol of religious or ethnic identity but a mental distinctiveness at work.

Is circumcision painful? Yes, undoubtedly, it is.[i] Only those who have never witnessed a circumcision or those who have been circumcised as infants may assume it is painless.[ii] The testimony of the latter, however, is unreliable as they have no memory of the dramatic event. Perhaps their bias towards circumcision betrays some deeper effects of the practice.

The immediate pain of circumcision was used to market it where pain was required. Thus, many African tribes have been easily persuaded to include circumcision in their rites of passage into adulthood by religious missionaries. These tribes use circumcision mainly as an inflictor of pain because they perceive maturity and responsibility as the ability to endure pain which eventually spread the bloody ritual over the fair sex too. The pain endurance test, however, is senseless and unacceptable to the western societies. Causing physical pain is an outdated educational approach for the democratic world. Nowadays it is recognized that both pain and sensorial deprivation has a lifelong psychological impact.

If the child were left uncircumcised for two or three years, this would necessitate the abandonment of circumcision because of the father’s love and affection for it. 
Moses Maimonides

Common naturals, many physicians and even Torah scholars do not doubt the obvious fact that circumcision is sore. In “The Guide to the Perplexed”, for instance, Maimonides reconfirms the obvious truth that circumcision is painful. He explains that an important reason for performing circumcision on infants is to prevent avoidance of the painful operation by adults. The emotional connection that parents have developed with their child may deter them from inflicting such pain to it, he clarifies. And, of course, if the boy is left to decide for himself when he grows up he will naturally circumvent circumcision. In other words, the scholar makes clear that circumcision must be enforced on helpless new-borns because to adults it is so painful that its practice would not survive. So even though circumcision is a painful hard thing the pain accompanying the operation is undesirable and is not its main intent. The post-mortem circumcisions such as those performed by the graveside on stillborn babies or adult Jews who were banned from circumcision also attest that pain is not an immediate priority of the practice.

Remembering your circumcision will make you think of God and thus help resist sex-lust. 
Talmud

But is the pain that comes afterwards the aim of religious circumcision? There is a great variety of opinions on this issue too due to the different understanding of the objective and the effects of the practice, of the definition of pain and due to the different probity of the parts. Religious sources point out that the main goal of circumcision is to foster spirituality which it achieves by frustrating sexuality. And this is reasonable to the common sense too. Circumcision causes dysfunction of genitalia and difficulties in sexual life. By reducing the pleasure of sex it redirects cravings toward loftier activities. The key objective of circumcision is to facilitate religiousness by causing a lifelong uneasiness, discomfort or mild pain in sexual matters. It is the spiritual effects of the sexual frustration what circumcision aims at. The hindrance in the sexual sphere is the principal instrument of the ultimate goal of the practice. The pain that circumcision intends is of psychological nature and concerns sexuality.

The bodily pain caused to that member is the real purpose of circumcision. … The fact that circumcision weakens the faculty of sexual excitement and sometimes perhaps diminishes the pleasure is indubitable. … this is the strongest of the reasons for circumcision. 
Moses Maimonides

Maimonides points out that causing pain to the member and restricting sexual pleasure is the main goal of circumcision. The famous Jewish philosopher states that circumcision aims at weakening the member and sexual desire. It serves to normalize men’s excessive sexuality so without hindering procreation room is left to develop more elevated attitudes such as moderation, piety, obedience and docility. Obviously, speaking of the pain caused to the member he means suppression of sexuality. Essentially, he pays attention to the primal importance of the long-term psychological effects of circumcision. Actually, he articulated the induction of the Circumcision complex about a millennium prior the establishment of psychology as a science.

Share →

Leave a Reply

Circumcision to Terrorism
Circumcision is not simply a cosmetic procedure performed ...
A Peace Mission
The circumcision complex divides the human race into sub-races […]
ponik shad
homunculus shad
The site needs your help in standing its ground.
If you find this work valuable,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex task is difficult but well worth the effort.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
Survival requires more than sympathy.
If you find this work important,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to cut through.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
Survival requires more than sympathy.
If you find this work progressive,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to cut through.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
This website relies on your goodwill.
If you find it valuable,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to cut through.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
This website relies on your goodwill.
If you find it valuable,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to cut through.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
This website relies on your goodwill.
If you find it valuable,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to cut through.
CLOSE
ponik shad
homunculus shad
Comparison of facts and feelings gives birth to truth.
If you find the site informative,
please support its author and developer.
The Circumcision Complex concept still has many things to tell.
CLOSE